Background
Discover

Papa Kelsey's Pizza & Subs Menu

Introducing the menu at Papa Kelsey's Pizza & Subs, where flavor and generous portions meet convenience. Located in Wendell, ID, this casual eatery has carved out a niche for itself along the busy route between Boise and Salt Lake City. Customers rave about the delicious pizzas and hearty subs, with one patron declaring it one of the best pizzas in the region.

The standout item? The Steak Firehouse sub, praised for its robust flavor and ample portions. It’s clear why people like Trent choose to indulge here often, while others relish the huge kid's cones that exceed expectations. Beyond the food, the warm, friendly atmosphere encourages customers to linger and enjoy.

Whether you're stopping for a quick bite or a leisurely meal, Papa Kelsey’s promises a delightful experience worth returning for.

Background

Drinks

Background

Daily Lunch Specials

Background

Soups & Salads

Background

Papa Kelsey's Breakfast Menu

Background

Sides

Background

Pizzas

Background

Kid's Menu

Background

Desserts

Background

Sauces & Dressings

Background

Meals