Hello dear
Welcome To Papa Kelsey's Pizza & Subs
Papa Kelsey's Pizza & Subs, located at 379 S Idaho St in Wendell, ID, has quickly become a must-visit for locals and travelers alike. Renowned for its hearty portions and friendly service, this eatery serves delicious pizzas and subs that cater to all tastes. Customer favorites include the flavorful Steak Firehouse sub and the highly praised ham and cheese. Diners appreciate the casual atmosphere and the cleanliness of the establishment. Whether you're grabbing lunch on a road trip or seeking a cozy dining experience, Papa Kelsey's is dedicated to making every meal memorable. Don't forget to try their generous ice cream cones!
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
Kids Drink 12 Oz
US$2.5916oz. Small Cup Of Ranch
US$7.53Mac & Cheese
US$7.79
Breadsticks
US$7.79Mozzarella Sticks
US$10.39French Fries
US$0.00
Pizza Bomb
US$11.69Kid's Menu
US$8.44Cookie (1)
US$1.68 About
Papa Kelsey's Pizza & Subs
Welcome to Papa Kelsey's Pizza & Subs, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Wendell, Idaho. Conveniently located at 379 S Idaho St, this charming eatery invites travelers and locals alike to indulge in a delightful culinary experience. Whether you’re passing through on a road trip or simply in search of a hearty meal, Papa Kelsey’s promises a warm welcome and a menu that will leave you craving more.
As soon as you step inside, the casual atmosphere envelops you, making it the perfect spot for a relaxed dining experience. The friendly staff instantly make you feel at home, ready to assist you in navigating their robust menu filled with mouth-watering pizzas and subs. According to customer reviews, the food here speaks volumes about the quality and flavor, as evidenced by diners like Locke Seavello, who raved about the Steak Firehouse sub, praising its generous portion sizes and delicious taste.
Pizza lovers will find themselves in paradise with Papa Kelsey’s renowned pies. Jessica Avalanche couldn’t help but declare it one of the best pizzas in the region, moving it to a must-stop destination every time she’s en route. The crust is perfectly cooked, and the toppings are fresh, ensuring a flavor explosion with every bite. If a classic ham and cheese sandwich is more your style, regulars like Trent Siler's wife swear by it, illustrating how this eatery captivates all palates.
The attention to detail extends beyond main dishes. Many patrons note the larger-than-life “kid’s cone” ice cream that outshines expectations, reinforcing the idea that at Papa Kelsey’s, no one leaves hungry. The clean and inviting interior further enhances the dining experience, making it a great choice for families and friends alike. Eduardo Martinez even emphasizes the cleanliness and friendliness of the establishment as standout features.
In conclusion, Papa Kelsey's Pizza & Subs is not just a place to grab a meal; it's a destination for flavor and comfort. With glowing reviews and a loyal customer base, it’s clear that this spot is dedicated to providing memorable dining experiences. Don’t miss out on your chance to savor a slice of pizza heaven or a satisfying sub on your next visit to Wendell.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Stopped in for lunch during a road trip from Boise to Salt Lake City. I had a Steak Firehouse and it was absolutely delicious. The portion sizes are huge too. We saw someone get a "kid's cone" ice cream and it was much bigger than most ice cream places. My only complaint, which is very minor, was that my sub was a little over toasted and the bread was falling apart as a result. ”
“ By war one of the best pizzas in the region. It was worth friving off the freeway for this pizza. Our new must stop by place whenever we're driving by ”
“ This is one of my wife's favorites. She especially loves the ham and cheese and would gladly eat here multiple times a week if our budget could handle it. ”
“ Found this restaurant online and decided to try it. Had a salad and sandwich. Everything tasted very good. Staff was friendly and helpful. Atmosphere is casual and comfortable. I would definitely come back. ”
“ Workers are very friendly. Pizza is great. And very clean inside. Highly recommend it! ”
“ The food is SO GOOD! You need to go here! I've had the subs before and they blow my mind. I had a breakfast burrito and it was perfection! My friend got the breakfast pizza and it looked really good too! She said it was. It was super cold there but the food warmed us up. ”
“ Excellent service and excellent food. Seriously the staff was so nice. ”
“ I'm not going to lie the fact that they make their own ranch without soybean oil and using real buttermilk that is so awesome their chicken bacon ranch sub and pizza is phenomenal their food here is just awesome has a truck driver who travels the country this is definitely a really good pizza joint ”